As an engineering academic, I spend my working life on creating good design: design that works, looks nice and doesn't destroy the planet. Products become obsolete when something faster, better or cheaper arrives. We improve things. That’s the whole point.
This blog is about a special category of products. Products we’ve been using for years. Products that are still bought, still sold, still everywhere, but are functionally useless. Some of us love them, while others are forced to use them. So, this is a tribute to humanity's greatest achievement: our stubbornness in refusing to improve things that obviously need it.
The business jacket
Take the classic business jacket. Nice collar, fancy lapels, very "I have an important engagement." It was originally designed for outdoor use, so let's ask the engineering question: what does it actually do?
In winter, nothing. It hangs open at the front, often held shut by a single button, and the sleeves are open too. The cold simply says, "Oh brilliant, multiple entry points."
In a proper summer, it is worse. It stops being a jacket and becomes a personal sauna, yet you have an important meeting, so you wear it anyway.
Indoors, the story repeats. Wear it in winter and the room needs heating. Wear it in summer and the building needs air conditioning. The jacket doesn't adapt to the environment; the environment has to adapt to the jacket.
Then there are the lapels and the collar. What is all that extra fabric doing? Nothing. You have an exposed chest, prime real estate for warmth, and we cover it with decorative flaps. Apparently, they are there to frame your face. I didn't realise I was a Renaissance painting.
To summarise, the business jacket: doesn't keep me warm; doesn't keep me cool; wastes material; increases energy consumption.
But it makes me look important. Which, perhaps, is the most functional thing in business.
Business suit trousers
Trousers come in every size: 36-30, 36-32, 36-34, 36-36, then 38-30, 38-32 and so on. They come in every shape too: skinny, slim, straight, regular, relaxed. Despite this incredible range, I still can't find a proper fit. Somehow, I am not included in the entire global trouser dataset. Can two numbers, waist and inseam, personise the entire population. A fit that works at the waist often gaps at the back or is tight across the thighs, and fixing one makes another worse.
And when they do fit, they don't work. Try to lift your leg and you meet resistance. Your muscles evolved to climb mountains, run and cycle, and instead they are locked in a power struggle with your pants. It's you versus your trousers, and the trousers are winning. Millions of years of evolution, defeated by your leg wear.
Tracksuits
Now compare tracksuits with business suits.
Tracksuits are designed around what the wearer actually does.
Temperature control: A full-length zip in a tracksuit top lets you open or close the front to regulate heat. Unlike business jackets elastic or ribbed cuffs and hem seal in warmth.
Movement: Stretch fabric and a looser cut let you reach, lift and bend. In a business jacket raising your arms drags the whole thing up your back. Stretch fabric lets you squat, climb, cycle or lift a leg without resistance. And when you sit there is no waistband or belt digging in.
The fit: Stretch in tracksuits is forgiving across sizes, since a tracksuit top doesn’t need an exact fit to work. Tracksuit bottoms work with the body instead of against it. An elastic waist and drawstring adjust to whatever size you are that day, after a big meal or after the occasional intermittent fast. They require a small number of broad sizes (S, M, L) and tolerate the variation in between. Seat, thigh and rise matter far less, because the fabric stretches to cover the differences. Tracksuits don't judge you. They say, "Whatever size you are today, we support you, emotionally and structurally."
Usage: You can machine wash it, while business suits usually need dry cleaning, which is not only expensive but also uses chemicals. Zipped pockets keep your phone and keys secure. It packs small and doesn’t crease, which is useful for travel.
Sustainability: Fewer materials are wasted, with no decorative lapels or padded shoulders. One garment covers sport, travel and casual wear, so you need fewer items overall.
So why do we look down on people wearing tracksuits. Just try wearing them to a nice restaurant and watch the reaction.
So let me get this straight. The best-designed clothing we have, the most comfortable, flexible and inclusive, is socially reserved for people who have completely lost control of their lives. The worst-designed clothing is what we wear to look successful.
Our society has gone irrational, and the change needs to come from above. Only when our lawmakers, our MPs and MSPs, start wearing tracksuits in their parliaments will I believe they can make rational decisions.
Jeans: where damage adds value
We can't talk about trousers without mentioning the most popular version of all: blue denim jeans. They began as clothing for factory workers and farmers – real hardworking people. Then James Dean wore them in Rebel Without a Cause and made them fashionable. So far so good.
But there was one problem: they faded in high stress areas, the knees and hips. Fading is something you would want to avoid in clothing. But for jeans the companies looked at the damage and said, "Write that down. That's a feature from now on."
Then came the punk movement of the 1970s, anti-capitalist and anti-corporate. They ripped their jeans and added safety pins to say, "We reject consumerism!" Corporations saw that and said, "Brilliant. Let's mass-produce rebellion."
Now you can walk into a store and pay £200 for jeans that look like you lost a fight with a lawnmower. They are called "distressed fit." Distressed? Mate, I'm cool; it's my jeans that are distressed. They even pre-rip them for you. We don't have time to ruin our own clothes anymore, so the factory adds the wrinkles, fading and tears. All those extra processes, the chemicals, the distressing, the artificial ageing, are bad for workers and bad for the planet. But we love it.
We took something durable, practical and built to last, and asked: what if it looked worse, lasted less and cost more? That is a brilliant business model. Jeans are the only product where damage increases value. I wish it worked for cars: I have a 2009 hatchback - pre-crashed, naturally distressed, one-of-a-kind."